Guide to the Catalogue

Welcome to Roy Lichtenstein: A Catalogue Raisonné, a digital publication by the Roy Lichtenstein Foundation that provides a comprehensive account of all known paintings, sculptures, drawings, collages, prints, commissions and other artworks by Roy Lichtenstein (1923–97). It was launched on the occasion of the artist's centennial in October 2023.

The chapters in this guide outline the scope of our catalogue raisonné project, specify research methodology and resources used, and define the organizational principles that inform the catalogue entries.

The content on these pages was created from documentation that does not necessarily reflect the Roy Lichtenstein Foundation's complete or current knowledge. Review and updating of records is ongoing.

 

Classification: Rowlux/Plastic

From 1963 to 1967 Lichtenstein produced over 100 unique landscape and seascape compositions collaged from plastic sheets with unique optical properties. One type, sold under the brand name Rowlux™, is an illusionistic plastic exhibiting different three-dimensional patterns that move and change with viewing angle. The artist experimented also with mirrored, iridescent and colored plastic sheets as well as other collage materials. Starting in 1966, he introduced motors to add motion to certain parts of the image and motorized lamps to cast colored light.

Lichtenstein chose simple aluminum frames to hold the loose sheets together and to cover irregular collaged edges for a more finished look. Thus, frames are integral to Rowlux/plastic works.

In this catalogue, the classification Rowlux/plastic is applied to unique works; editions made with Rowlux and plastic sheets are classified as prints.

Images

A Primary Image shows a work in its original frame when such photograph was available.

A work is pictured unframed when the original frame was lost or removed at the time of photography. In these cases, when available, Research Images show the original frame.

For this catalogue, photographs of unframed works were cropped just inside the edges of the collaged elements. Works photographed in non-original frames were cropped to just inside the edges of the frame or mat.

For works with lamps, images show the lamp attached to the original frame and document the lamps' changing colors, whenever such photographs are available.

Titles

The Rowlux works have had many titles over the years used by the artist, galleries and in exhibitions, generally Landscape or Seascape. Titles of Rowlux/plastic works are usually derived from the Castelli inventory. When there were several title options available, the more specific title was chosen.

Dates

Lichtenstein signed and dated the versos of many Rowlux/plastic works. When a verso was not accessible, the date given in the catalogue entry is primarily sourced from the Castelli inventory and RL Studio Cards.

See also: 8. DATES

Media

All visible media on the artwork's recto is described. Excluded are methods of attachment (e.g., liquid adhesive, pressure-sensitive adhesive film), which are invisible from the recto, though attachment is implied.

Collage elements usually overlap and may be adhered to each other rather than just to the support. Instead of describing the nexus of attachments, all media are listed, followed by the support (usually "board"), followed by the frame when relevant. Media are provided in the order of visual predominance, usually corresponding to the amount of space they take up.

Type and characteristics of original frames are added. The framer’s name is added when known. For Rowlux/plastic works with motorized lamps, the lamp is described, including the color sequence when documented. Color terminology is applied per the authors’ best judgement based on the available documentation.

In some cases, elements original to the works, like frames and lamps, or collage elements, are now lost. When written or visual documentation (e.g., correspondence with owners, conservation reports, installation photographs) confirms previous existence, "originally" is added before the missing material.  

Dimensions

Entries include image, board and frame dimensions as available. 

Image dimensions reflect measurements of the outer edges of any collaged elements
Board dimensions reflect measurements of the primary support (equal in size or slightly larger than the image)
Frame dimensions reflect measurements of an original frame

Dimensions without a prefix (see "Prefixes" in 10. DIMENSIONS) either give the overall size (usually the board size) or reflect dimensions given in a source, which is then indicated in Remarks.

Sight dimensions are given for works in non-original frames when they could not be unframed for examination. 

Whenever a work could not be examined, every effort was made to provide information from other sources, and the source is cited in Remarks.

See also: 10. DIMENSIONS

Signature, Inscriptions and Marks

Signatures on Rowlux/plastic works are usually on the verso and in graphite pencil. Motorized works were signed on the verso of the wood backing board of the frame.

See also: 11. INSCRIPTIONS

Media Details

No analytical testing for plastic identification was conducted. In this catalogue, the following terms have been used:

Rowlux refers to colorful, plastic sheets with different surface textures that create the illusion of three-dimensional patterns that move and change with viewing angle. It was produced by Rowland Technologies. At the time Lichtenstein was working with Rowlux, it was likely being cast in polycarbonate (Oral history interview with Rowland Technologies employee Joseph Wandy by Clare Bell, April 2009).  

Vinyl refers to solid black plastic sheets found in approximately 20 works. The Castelli inventory identifies black plastic in several works as vinyl. This term was used for all works showing what is assumed to be the same material.

Mirrored plastic refers to sheets that reflect their surroundings like mirrors. Mirrored plastic in Rowlux/plastic works range from silver to gold. Some have aged poorly, resulting in color shifts and reduction of reflectivity. Plastic ID is unknown.

Iridescent plastic refers to sheets that exhibit iridescence, or color change contingent on viewing angle. In at least one example, RLCR 1332, the iridescent plastic is laminated to paper. Plastic ID is unknown.

Screenprinted (?) plastic refers to sheets coated with multiple colors of paint or ink. Question mark in related entries indicate uncertainty. Plastic ID is unknown.

Lenticular print refers to an image that changes with viewing angle (e.g., the Vari-Vue print in RLCR 1314). Simplified, the surface "lens" is grooved plastic that is laminated to a printed image. Plastic ID is unknown.

Plastic refers to solid-colored plastic sheets for which plastic ID is unknown.

Acetate refers to clear plastic found in RLCR 1228, called as such following the related RL Studio Card. The artist was known to have used clear plastic sheets that his studio referred to as acetate, though plastic ID is not confirmed. 

See also: 4.5. COLLAGE

Supports and Frames

Board is the primary support of most non-motorized Rowlux/plastic works. It is typically 4-ply, white to cream mat board. Most boards are approximately the same size as collage elements and hidden when framed. Some boards are slightly longer in height and width than collage elements and visible when framed. Only in rare cases no board is found and Rowlux serves as the primary support (e.g., RLCR 948).

Welded aluminum frame is an original frame made of aluminum with “seamless” welded joints, polished edges and glass glazing. To the best of the authors’ understanding, Rowlux/plastic works were given welded aluminum frames, with the exceptions of a few works that received different types of frames (see other types, below) and the studies for prints, out of which just RLCR 948 was given a welded aluminum frame. Today, the frame status varies; works have been unframed, reframed, or retain original frames. When welded aluminum frame is listed in the media line, it means the work still possesses its original frame, or that there is clear photographic or written evidence of the frame’s existence in the past. Although most works are assumed to have received frames originally, a frame is not listed in the media line unless there is concrete evidence of its existence. Non-original frames are not addressed.

When the framer is known or assumed, the name is added. The two primary framers for Lichtenstein's Rowlux/plastic works were:

Kulicke Framers, Inc.: There are labels on 6 frames identifying Kulicke Framers, Inc. Based on material and structural consistencies with the labeled frames, at least one other frame is assumed to be by Kulicke.

Dain/Schiff Picture Framers, Inc.: There are labels on two frames identifying Dain/Schiff Picture Framers, Inc. Of the remaining frames the authors ascertained that approximately 30 more are likely Dain/Schiff frames.

Kulicke and Dain/Schiff frames are nearly identical from the front, but distinguishable from the back and sides. Kulicke frames have screws on the sides where the frame is attached to a wooden strainer. Dain/Schiff frames have metal clips on the back which secure the frame around a wooden strainer. Both framers were located steps away from Leo Castelli Gallery at the time of production of the Rowlux/plastic works.

Metal section frame refers to a customizable aluminum frame made from four lengths of metal “sections” attached with corner braces from the back. 

There are two works that have additional types of frames: RLCR 1137 was given an all-Plexiglas box frame (developed by Robert Kulicke in 1964 and called Plexibox frame by Kulicke Framers, Inc.). RLCR 1126 has a bespoke, silver-painted wood frame. 

Motorized Works and Lamps

Motor refers to an electric motor attached to the frame backing board, used to animate collage elements to mimic the swell of waves. Motors are plugged into electrical outlets to function and controlled by dials on the backs of the frames. Invoices in the Estate Archives dated 1966 indicate that Lichtenstein purchased motors and electrical equipment from: Refrigeration Trading Co.; Blan: The Radio Man, Inc.; Weiss Hardware Manufacturing Co., Inc., and Guardino & Schooler, Inc.

Welded aluminum frames were used for motorized works. They were likely built by Dain/Schiff Picture Framers, Inc., and included white to cream window mats. In place of a wood strainer on the back there is a wood backing board and wood spacers for motorized parts. A media line says "frame" even when it was impossible to confirm a frame's originality, because these motorized works are incomplete and do not function without frames.

Wood refers to the wood backing board, spacers and other parts comprising the frame box of motorized works. Typically, frame parts that are invisible from the recto are not commented on, but these parts are understood as being critical to the function and form of the works.

Motorized lamp refers to a cylindrical lamp meant to be attached to a frame. The lamp is comprised of a bulb surrounded by a rotating drum painted by the artist so that it radiates changing colors of light onto a work’s surface in a repeating sequence. A lighting technician and Lichtenstein’s then brother-in-law, Howard Brandston, helped the artist tailor the lamps. They had to be plugged into electrical outlets to function. Lichtenstein once indicated that works with lamps could be exhibited with or without the lamp. Works that have been exhibited with a lamp have a distinctive pair of screw holes on the back of the frame’s wooden strainer.

Catalogue Terms & Conditions

These Terms and Conditions (“Terms”) set forth the terms and conditions of your use of the digital publication “Roy Lichtenstein: A Catalogue Raisonné”  (the “Catalogue Raisonné”) available at www.lichtensteincatalogue.org (the “Site”), a project of the Roy Lichtenstein Foundation (referred to as “RLF,” “us,” “we,” or “our”).

Please read these Terms carefully.  By accessing and using the Site, you agree to be bound by and comply with the Terms.  If you do not agree to these Terms, you may not access the Site or use any of the information or Content (as defined below) therein.

Reliance on Information Posted

The Content (as defined below) presented on or through the Site is made available solely for general information purposes.  We do not make any representation or warranty as to the accuracy, completeness or usefulness of this Content.  Any reliance you place on such Content is strictly at your own risk. WE DISCLAIM ALL LIABILITY AND RESPONSIBILITY ARISING FROM ANY RELIANCE PLACED ON THE CONTENT BY YOU OR ANY OTHER VISITOR TO THE SITE, OR BY ANYONE WHO MAY BE INFORMED OF ANY OF ITS CONTENTS. 

The Catalogue Raisonné is subject to change.  RLF endeavored to make the Catalogue Raisonné as complete as possible as of the time of online publication.  As new information and images emerge regarding the works of Roy Lichtenstein, RLF will work to make updates to the Catalogue Raisonné.  

Inclusions in Catalogue Raisonné (or Lack Thereof)

Neither RLF nor the Estate of Roy Lichtenstein authenticates artworks, and the inclusion of an artwork in the Catalogue Raisonné does not serve as a warranty or guarantee of that artwork’s authenticity or provenance.  In addition, the fact that an artwork has not been included in the Catalogue Raisonné does not necessarily mean that such artwork is not by Roy Lichtenstein.

Copyright & Trademark

“ROY LICHTENSTEIN” is a federally registered trademark of the Estate of Roy Lichtenstein. All other trademarks and trade dress displayed in this website are trademarks and trade dress of the Estate of Roy Lichtenstein, RLF, or of their respective owners. “ROY LICHTENSTEIN” and other trademarks and trade dress used in the website may not be used as trademarks without the prior written authorization of the Estate of Roy Lichtenstein or the respective owners of the trademarks.

All of the content featured or displayed on the Site and in the Catalogue Raisonné, including, but not limited to, images of works of art by Roy Lichtenstein, text, photographs and other materials, as well as the selection and arrangement of materials in the Site (collectively, “Content”), is protected by copyright law and owned by the Estate of Roy Lichtenstein, RLF, or of their respective licensors. 

Except as expressly set forth in these Terms, nothing contained on the Site shall be construed as conferring any license or right to any copyright or trademark used on this Site.

Permitted Uses

Provided that you comply with these Terms, we grant you a personal, revocable, limited, non-exclusive, royalty-free, non-transferable, non-sublicensable license to use this Site solely for your personal, non-commercial, educational and research purposes.  You may not make any other use of the Site or any of the Content without prior written permission from RLF or the entity(ies) or individual(s) RLF designates for purposes of granting or withholding the relevant permission(s).  To request such permission, please contact [email protected]. 

The images, text and source material in the Site may be protected by third-party copyright or trademark.  No license is granted to you under any such third-party rights.

Prohibited Uses

Notwithstanding the foregoing, you may not (i) download, or attempt to download, any reproduction or image of any work of art, (ii) remove or alter any copyright, trademark or other proprietary notices from any of the Content or (iii) modify, translate, decompile, create derivative work(s) of, copy, distribute, or otherwise use in any manner not expressly permitted herein, the Site.  Specifically, and by way of illustration and not limitation, you may not separate any graphics, photographs or other elements from the accompanying text or material in the Site without the prior express written permission of RLF and/or its licensor(s). 

You may not use the Site in any way that violates any applicable federal, state, local or international law or regulation (including, without limitation, any laws regarding the export of data or software to and from the US or other countries).

You may not use any “deep-link”, “page-scrape”, “robot”, “spider” or other automatic device, program, algorithm or methodology, or any similar or equivalent manual process, to access, extract, acquire, copy or monitor any portion of the Site or any Content, or in any way reproduce or circumvent the navigational structure or presentation of the Site or any Content, to obtain or attempt to obtain any materials, documents or information through any means not purposely made available through the Site.  

No Content accessed from the Site may be used to train artificial intelligence models or tools or otherwise for generating output or other content using artificial intelligence technologies, or to permit others to do the same.  

You further agree that you will not:

  1. Interfere with the proper functioning of the Site;
  2. Attempt to gain unauthorized access to any portion or feature of the Site, or any other systems or networks connected to the Site or to any RLF server, or to any of the services offered on or through the Site, by hacking, password “mining” or any other illegitimate means; or
  3. Probe, scan or test the vulnerability of the Site or any network connected to the Site, nor breach the security or authentication measures on the Site or any network connected to the Site. 

Registered Users

If you are 18 years old or older, you may register to become a registered user (“Registered User”) and access the Site. You are responsible for all activity under your Registered User account.  You agree to provide accurate, current and complete information at all times, and to update it in a timely manner.  You may not transfer or otherwise do anything to give another person access to your Registered User account.  You must notify us immediately at [email protected] if you become aware that anyone has gained unauthorized access to your Registered User account.  You represent and warrant that all information you provide as a Registered User is accurate and complete.

We reserve the right, in our sole discretion, to suspend or terminate your registered access at any time if you have not complied with the Terms or for other reasons that we determine in good faith are necessary or appropriate, including if we suspect you are using or attempting to use the Site in any way that violates these Terms or any applicable laws or regulations.

Third-Party Content and Links to Third-Party Websites 

The Site may contain content of, or links to websites controlled by, third parties (“Third-Party Websites”).  We are not responsible for Third-Party Websites or their content, activities or privacy practices.  Any information you share or actions you take on Third-Party Websites are governed by those websites’ terms of use and privacy statements, which you should review carefully to learn about their practices.  The inclusion of third-party content or links to Third-Party Websites on our Site does not imply our endorsement of Third-Party Websites, their content, or any associated organization or activity.  We make no representation or warranty whatsoever about the nature of Third-Party Websites and if you decide to access any other websites linked to or from the Site, you do so entirely at your own risk.  WE ARE NOT RESPONSIBLE, OR LIABLE TO YOU OR ANY THIRD PARTY, FOR THE CONTENT OR ACCURACY OF ANY MATERIALS PROVIDED BY ANY THIRD PARTIES.

Frames; Metatags

Unless you obtain our prior written consent in each case, you may not: (A) frame any Content on any other website; or (B) use metatags or any other “hidden text” that incorporates the “ROY LICHTENSTEIN” trademarks, marks confusingly similar to our trademarks, or our name.

Additional Disclaimers

THE SITE, CONTENT, AND LINKS AVAILABLE THROUGH IT ARE AVAILABLE “AS IS” AND “AS AVAILABLE.”  WE DO NOT WARRANT THAT THE SITE OR ANY CONTENT AND LINKS AVAILABLE THROUGH IT WILL BE UNINTERRUPTED OR ERROR-FREE.  THERE MAY BE DELAYS, OMISSIONS, INTERRUPTIONS AND INACCURACIES IN CONTENT AVAILABLE ON THE SITE.  WE MAKE NO REPRESENTATIONS OR WARRANTIES ABOUT THE ACCURACY, COMPLETENESS, TIMELINESS, RELIABILITY, OR NON-INFRINGEMENT OF ANY CONTENT AVAILABLE ON THE SITE OR CONTENT OR SERVICES AVAILABLE THROUGH LINKS TO THIRD-PARTY WEB SITES.  WE RESERVE THE RIGHT TO CORRECT ANY ERRORS OR OMISSIONS ON THE SITE AND IN ITS CONTENT.  IF YOU RELY ON THE SITE AND ANY CONTENT AVAILABLE THROUGH IT, YOU DO SO ENTIRELY AT YOUR OWN RISK.

TO THE MAXIMUM EXTENT PERMITTED UNDER LAW, RLF DISCLAIMS ANY AND ALL EXPRESS OR IMPLIED WARRANTIES WITH RESPECT TO THE SITE AND ANY CONTENT OR INFORMATION THAT IS AVAILABLE THROUGH IT, INCLUDING WITHOUT LIMITATION, ANY WARRANTY OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE (EVEN IF THAT PURPOSE HAS BEEN DISCLOSED).

ALTHOUGH RLF INTENDS TO TAKE REASONABLE STEPS TO PREVENT THE INTRODUCTION OF VIRUSES, WORMS, “TROJAN HORSES,” OR OTHER MALICIOUS CODE TO THE SITE, RLF DOES NOT GUARANTEE OR WARRANT THAT THE SITE, OR CONTENT THAT MAY BE AVAILABLE THROUGH IT, ARE FREE FROM SUCH DESTRUCTIVE FEATURES.  RLF IS NOT LIABLE FOR ANY DAMAGES OR HARM ATTRIBUTABLE TO SUCH FEATURES.

Limitation of Liability

RLF AND ITS AFFILIATES, MANAGERS, OFFICERS, EMPLOYEES, CONTRACTORS, AGENTS, VOLUNTEERS, AND ADVISORS, WHETHER IN SUCH CAPACITIES OR INDIVIDUALLY, AND THE HEIRS, SUCCESSORS AND ASSIGNS OF EACH OF THEM (TOGETHER, THE “COVERED PARTIES”) ARE NOT LIABLE FOR ANY CLAIM OF ANY NATURE WHATSOEVER BASED ON LOSS OR INJURY BECAUSE OF ERRORS, OMISSIONS, INTERRUPTIONS, OR INACCURACIES IN THE SITE OR ANY CONTENT AVAILABLE THROUGH IT, INCLUDING LOSS OR INJURY THAT RESULTS FROM YOUR BREACH OF ANY PROVISION OF THESE TERMS.

UNDER NO CIRCUMSTANCES WILL RLF OR THE COVERED PARTIES BE LIABLE FOR ANY DIRECT, INDIRECT, INCIDENTAL, CONSEQUENTIAL, SPECIAL, PUNITIVE, OR EXEMPLARY DAMAGES (INCLUDING LOST REVENUES OR PROFITS, LOSS OF BUSINESS, OR LOSS OF DATA) ARISING OUT OF OR IN CONNECTION WITH YOUR USE OF THE SITE OR CONTENT OR THESE TERMS, REGARDLESS OF THE THEORY OF LIABILITY, WHETHER TORT (INCLUDING NEGLIGENCE), CONTRACT, OR ANY OTHER LEGAL OR EQUITABLE THEORY, EVEN IF RLF HAS BEEN ADVISED OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH DAMAGES.  OUR AGGREGATE LIABILITY TO YOU FOR ANY USE OF, OR INABILITY TO USE, THE SITE OR CONTENT IS LIMITED TO $1000. SOME STATES DO NOT ALLOW THE LIMITATION OF LIABILITY FOR THESE KINDS OF DAMAGES, SO THESE LIMITATIONS OR EXCLUSIONS MAY NOT APPLY TO YOU.

Indemnification

You agree to indemnify, defend and hold harmless RLF and the Covered Parties from and against all demands, loss, liability, claims or expenses (including attorneys’ fees) made against RLF and the Covered Parties arising out of your use of the Site, its Content, or violation of these Terms.

Infringing Material

RLF respects the intellectual property of others and expects users to do the same.  As to allegedly infringing copyrighted works, we comply with the take down and counter notification provisions of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (“DMCA”), 17 U.S.C.A. § 512, as set forth below. 

We reserve the right to remove or disable access to any Content claimed to be infringing, at any time at our sole discretion, without notice or liability.  In appropriate circumstances, we will also terminate users of the Site who are repeat infringers.

If you believe that Content has been used in a way that constitutes copyright infringement, please provide our designated agent, whose contact information is listed below, with a written notice containing all of the following information (“DMCA Notice”):

  • A physical or electronic signature of a person authorized to act on behalf of the owner of an exclusive right that is allegedly infringed;
  • Identification of the copyrighted work claimed to have been infringed;
  • Identification of the Content that is claimed to be infringing or to be the subject of infringing activity, and information reasonably sufficient to permit us to locate such Content on our Site (such as the URL to each page on the Site containing allegedly infringing material);
  • Information reasonably sufficient to permit us to contact you, such as an address, telephone number, and, if available, an email address;
  • a statement that you have a good faith belief that use of the Content in the manner complained of is not authorized by the copyright owner, its agent, or the law; and
  • a statement that the information in your notice is accurate and, under penalty of perjury, that you are authorized to act on behalf of the owner of an exclusive right that is allegedly infringed.

Our agent designated to receive DMCA Notices may be contacted as follows:

[email protected]

Changes to the Terms

RLF may change these Terms from time to time by posting an updated version on this web page, or, if we determine that it is appropriate, we may provide other notice to you.  Your continued use of the Site after we post updated Terms means that you accept and agree to such Terms.  We recommend checking back on this web page regularly if you use the Site.

Termination

We reserve the right to terminate the Site, these Terms, and any Content, and your access to the Site and/or the Content, at any time without notice, for any reason.  The “Reliance on Information Posted,” “Copyright & Trademark,” “Inclusions in Catalogue Raisonné (or Lack Thereof),” “Additional Disclaimers,” “Limitation of Liability,” “Indemnification,” and “Governing Law” sections of these Terms (along with this provision and any other provision that by its terms contemplates survival) survive any termination of these Terms.

Governing Law

These Terms are the complete agreement between you and RLF regarding your use of the Site and is governed by applicable federal laws and the laws of the State of New York applicable to agreements made and completely performed there.  Any dispute arising out of or in connection with these Terms shall be subject to the exclusive jurisdiction and venue of the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York located in the Borough of Manhattan in the City of New York or, only if such court does not have subject-matter jurisdiction, the Supreme Court of the State of New York, New York County.

You irrevocably agree to bring any claim or dispute relating to your use of the Site and these Terms exclusively in the state and federal courts located in New York, to submit to the exclusive jurisdiction of those courts, and to waive any jurisdictional, venue, inconvenient forum, or other objections to those courts.  

Other

Section titles and headings are for convenience only and have no legal or contractual effect.  The failure of RLF to exercise or enforce any right or provision of the Terms shall not constitute a waiver of such right or provision.  If a court of competent jurisdiction determines that any provision of these Terms is unenforceable for any reason, then that provision will be deleted and the remaining provisions of these Terms will be enforceable to the fullest extent permitted by law.

Questions

Please email [email protected] with any questions you may have about these Terms.